NEW DELHI/KOLKATA — The political confrontation between Prime Minister Narendra Modi and West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee reached a fever pitch on Monday. Following a weekend of traded barbs over President Droupadi Murmu’s visit to Bengal, the Trinamool Congress (TMC) launched a sharp visual counter-attack, using a 2024 photograph to question the Prime Minister’s own respect for the presidential office.
The row, which began over alleged protocol lapses during the President’s trip to Darjeeling, has now evolved into a high-stakes battle over tribal empowerment and constitutional decorum.
The Photo Controversy
During a public rally, TMC leaders displayed a photograph from March 31, 2024, taken during the Bharat Ratna investiture for BJP veteran Lal Krishna Advani.
-
The TMC’s Argument: Banerjee pointed out that in the image, President Murmu is seen standing while Prime Minister Modi remains seated.
-
The Quote: “The country’s first tribal woman President stands while the Prime Minister sits comfortably in his chair,” the TMC stated. “All proclamations of respect for the President ring hollow when visual evidence reveals such casual disregard.”
Origins of the Dispute: The Darjeeling Visit
The tension ignited on Saturday during the 9th International Santal Conference in Darjeeling. President Murmu expressed public disappointment over the absence of the Chief Minister and senior state officials at the event.
| Stakeholder | Perspective |
| President Murmu | Expressed sadness that the CM or ministers did not receive her; flagged the “difficult” venue choice by the state. |
| PM Narendra Modi | Called the incident “shameful and unprecedented,” accusing the TMC of insulting the Constitution and the tribal community. |
| Mamata Banerjee | Denied any protocol lapse, stating the event was private and the state had warned of “inadequate arrangements” beforehand. |
Administrative Fallout: Home Ministry Steps In
The dispute has moved beyond political rhetoric into official scrutiny. Union Home Secretary Govind Mohan has formally sought a report from West Bengal Chief Secretary Nandini Chakravorty regarding specific alleged lapses:
-
Absence of Top Brass: Why the CM, Chief Secretary, and DGP were not present for the arrival/departure.
-
Basic Amenities: Reports of no water in the President’s designated washroom.
-
Sanitation: Allegations that the President’s travel route was laden with garbage.
-
Accountability: Questions regarding potential disciplinary action against the DM of Darjeeling and the Siliguri Police Commissioner.
The “Vote Bird” Retort
Responding to the Prime Minister’s criticism, Banerjee labeled him a “vote bird” who visits Bengal only before elections to make accusations. She maintained that since she was not part of the official “lineup” or “dais plan” approved by the President’s Secretariat, her absence did not constitute a breach of protocol.
